Alexanders On The Water

Located on the serene shores at 369 W Jackson St in Cicero, Indiana, Alexanders On The Water is more than just an ice cream shop—it's a beloved local gem where unforgettable memories are made against the backdrop of a sparkling lake. This charming spot offers a delightfully unique combination of classic ice cream indulgences paired with hearty, comforting food favorites that satisfy every craving.

Step into Alexanders and you’re immediately greeted by the inviting atmosphere where the gentle lake breeze and picturesque views set the scene for relaxation and joy. Families, friends, and dog owners alike find themselves lingering here, not just for the food but for the warm, friendly vibe that radiates from the smiling staff and happy patrons. As Hollie Nicholson fondly recalls, "You can’t beat the view or the atmosphere here... it feels like you're in a movie." Indeed, the vibe here feels timeless—like the perfect summer day captured in a treasured photograph.

While the shop’s reputation for premium, creamy ice cream is well-earned—with raving fans like Marianny Kingston rating it a “solid 1000000/10”—Alexanders boasts more than just sweet treats. The savory menu is surprisingly extensive and delicious. Indulge in their legendary Breaded Tenderloin Sandwich or the Jumbo Tenderloin Sandwich, both crafted to offer that perfect balance of crisp, flavorful breading and tender, juicy meat. For something lighter yet equally satisfying, their range of quesadillas—from Chicken to Cheese—delivers a melty, savory punch, while the Grilled Cheese Deluxe wraps childhood nostalgia in a warm, golden embrace.

Don’t overlook the sides: Beer Battered Onion Rings crackle with a satisfying crunch, and the unique Smiley Fries add a playful touch to your meal. For a fresher option, the Southern Fried Chicken Salad and Buffalo Crispy Chicken Salad bring vibrant, bold flavors paired with crisp greens, creating a perfect harmony for those seeking a well-rounded bite.

Customer experiences here radiate warmth and authenticity. Derek Summitt’s recount of his “dog enjoying the view and hanging out after her pup cup” perfectly encapsulates the welcoming environment—where every member of the family feels valued. Danton Harris notes the premium quality of their Butter Pecan and Cashew waffle cones, acknowledging that while the price might lean on the higher side, the generous portions and attentive, friendly service more than justify the expense.

In summer, the line may stretch, but it only adds to the excitement and community feel as you watch life play out on the water’s edge. Shannon McQuillen’s shout-out to the hardworking, efficient young team behind the counter speaks volumes about the passion and dedication fueling Alexanders’ success.

Whether you’re craving a nostalgic scoop of ice cream, a hearty sandwich, or simply a place to soak in the lakeside magic, Alexanders On The Water delivers an experience that’s nourishing for both the body and soul. It’s a vibrant, joyful destination that reminds us all of the simple pleasures—good food, great company, and a view that never gets old.